Search for:

The 3rd Panel of Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice (STJ) — the country’s highest court for non-constitutional matters — unanimously held, on October 06, 2026, in Special Appeal (REsp) 2.224.272, that Brazilian courts have jurisdiction to hear annulment actions against foreign arbitral awards if the parties, in their arbitration agreement, have chosen Brazilian law to govern the arbitral procedure and expressly designated Brazil as the venue for annulment proceedings. The ruling departs from the conventional understanding in Brazil that only courts at the seat of arbitration may entertain challenges to the validity of an arbitral award.

Factual Background

The underlying dispute concerned an arbitration formally seated in New York, in which the parties had nonetheless chosen Brazilian law to govern the procedural rules of the arbitration and had expressly designated São Paulo, Brazil, as the venue for any annulment proceedings. Following issuance of the award, the losing party commenced annulment proceedings before the São Paulo courts in reliance on those contractual provisions. The court of first instance dismissed the action on jurisdictional grounds, holding that, since the arbitration was formally seated in New York, annulment jurisdiction lay exclusively with the courts of that jurisdiction; This position was upheld on appeal, so that the plaintiff brought the matter before the STJ via a Special Appeal.

The Court Decision

The STJ’s decision rested on three principal lines of reasoning.

First, based on Article V(1)(e) of the 1958 New York Convention, reporting Justice Nancy Andrighi concluded that the Convention permits refusal of recognition and enforcement of an award set aside by a competent authority of the country “under the law of which” such award was made. This formulation is broad enough to accommodate the view that the law governing the arbitral procedure, rather than the law of the seat, determines which court holds jurisdiction for annulment proceedings. Since the parties had chosen Brazilian procedural law as the lex arbitri, the STJ held that Brazil qualifies as a country “under the law of which” the award was made within the meaning of the Convention.

Second, the Panel drew a distinction between an annulment action — a primary challenge to the validity of the award — and homologation, the separate procedure by which a foreign award is recognized in Brazil for enforcement purposes; these being entirely distinct mechanisms, the STJ’s exclusive competence over homologation does not preclude Brazilian courts of first instance from hearing an annulment action to the extent the parties have so agreed.

Third, the STJ referred to the principle of party autonomy, holding that the parties’ express contractual designation of São Paulo as the annulment venue constitutes a valid and binding choice.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways

The decision carries immediate practical consequences for the drafting of international arbitration clauses with any connection to Brazil. The formal seat of arbitration is not, under Brazilian law, an immutable determinant of annulment jurisdiction, and that parties may effectively delegate competence to Brazilian courts through arbitral agreement drafting. The ruling also invites further scrutiny of how Brazilian courts will interpret the New York Convention’s country-of-origin provisions in future enforcement proceedings in cases in which an award has been set aside in Brazil under such an expanded jurisdictional theory. The counsellors should review existing arbitration clauses and consider whether the alignment or misalignment of seat, procedural law, and designated annulment venue accurately reflects their clients’ actual risk preferences.

Author

Joaquim Muniz is a partner and head of the Arbitration team at Trench Rossi Watanabe. He has an LL.M. from the University of Chicago and is the president of the Association of Mediation and Arbitration Institutions with presence in Brazil (CONIMA).